Contents

1 Introduction..................................................................................................... 1

Thomas Bustamante and Bernardo Goncalves Fernandes

Part I Challenging and Defending Judicial Review

2 Randomized Judicial Review..........................................................................

Andrei Marmor

3 On the Difficulty to Ground the Authority

of Constitutional Courts: Can Strong

Judicial Review Be Morally Justified?............................................................ 29

Thomas Bustamante

4 Reason Without Vote: The Representative and

Majoritarian Function of Constitutional Courts.............................................. 71

Luis Roberto Barroso

Part II Constitutional Dialogues and Constitutional Deliberation

5 Decoupling Judicial Review from Judicial Supremacy................................... 93

Stephen Gardbaum

6 Scope and Limits of Dialogic Constitutionalism............................................ 119

Roberto Gargarella

7 A Defence of a Broader Sense of Constitutional Dialogues Based

on Jeremy Waldron’s Criticism on Judicial Review...................................... 147

Bernardo Goncalves Fernandes

Part III Institutional Alternatives for Constitutional Changes

8 New Institutional Mechanisms for Making Constitutional Law................. 167

Mark Tushnet

9 Democratic Constitutional Change:

Assessing Institutional Possibilities................................................................ 185

Christopher F. Zurn

10 The Unconstitutionality of Constitutional Amendments

in Colombia: The Tension Between Majoritarian

Democracy and Constitutional Democracy.................................................... 213

Gonzalo Andres Ramirez-Cleves

Part IV Constitutional Promises and Democratic Participation

11 Is There Such Thing as a Radical Constitution?........................................... 233

Vera Karam de Chueiri

12 Judicial Reference to Community

Values - A Pointer Towards Constitutional Juries?....................................... 247

Eric Ghosh

Part V Legal Theory and Constitutional Interpretation

13 Common Law Constitutionalism and the Written Constitution................. 275

Wil J. Waluchow and Katharina Stevens

14 On How Law Is Not Like Chess - Dworkin

and the Theory of Conceptual Types............................................................. 293

Ronaldo Porto Macedo Jr.

Index.................................................................................................................... 325