REACTION TRACKER TABLE

Statement Reaction of

Jai Chand Event 1: JC comes in (JC) Event 2: Sohan Singh (SS) comes in.

Event 3: Shail Munshi (SM) comes in.

Constraint: JC leaves with Deepak Garg (DG) leaving Jai Prakash (JP) and Vinod Rai (VR) in the bar.

Jai Prakash Event (Number not known): JP and VR enter.

(JP) Constraint: JC and someone else was there.

Shail Event: SM enters

Munshi Constraint: Meets JC, SS and DG

(SM)

Sohan Event x: SM leaves

Singh Event (x + 1): SS leaves

(SS)

Deepak Event: DG enters.

Garg (DG) Constraints: Meets SS, SM, JP and VR during his first visit.

Event: DG and JC leave.

Event: DG enters for second time.

Constraint: JP and VR are there when DG enters again. (No one else present)

Pradeep Event: PK enters

Kumar Constraint: Only JP and DG are present at this time.

(PK)

Vinod Rai No info.

(VR) Deductions: When JP and VR enter only 2 people are there. We also know the first 3 events—JC enters, SS enters and SM enters. Also, DG meets SC, SS, SM, JR & VR in his first visit.

This gives us that:

Event 4: DG enters

Event 5: SM leaves

Event 6: SS leaves

Event 7: JP and VR enter (at this time only JC and DG are there)

Event 8: JC and DG leave (Now only JP and VR are present)

Event 9: DG comes back again (now JP, VR and DG are inside)

Event 10: VR leaves (Since when PK enters only JP and DG are there)

Event 11: PK enters

Event 12: PK leaves

Hence the answers are:

35. DG enters before JP. Hence (b).

36. DG was sitting there (Event 7). Hence (c).

37. VR meets JC, DG and JP. He comes in after SM and SS have left and leaves before PK enters. Hence, he meets only 3 people. Hence (b).

38. JP and DG must be leaving last since they are there when PK leaves. Hence (d).

SET 11 Questions 39 to 42: