Table of Cases

Aberdeenshire County Council v Lord Glentanar 1999 SLT 1456..................................................... 248

Alba Homes Ltd v Duell 1993 SLT (Sh Ct) 49.......................................................................................

Armour v Thyssen Edelstahlwerke AG 1986 SLT 452 (Outer House), 1989 SLT 182

(Inner House), 1990 SLT 891 (House of Lords)................................................................... 205,............................................................................................................................................................... 234

Assessor for Argyll v Broadland Properties Ltd 1973 SC 152............................................................ 221

Bain v Carrick 1983 SLT 675.................................................................................................................. 174

Barbour v Halliday (1840) 2 D 1279.............................................................................................. 224,............................................................................................................................................................... 225

Barclays Bank v O'Brien [1994] 1 AC 180............................................................................................. 121

Barnett v Chelsea and Kensington Hospital Management Committee [1969] 1 QB 428................ 394

Baronetcy of Pringle of Stichill [2016] UKPC 16, 2016 SC (PC) 1.................................................... 122

Bartonshill Coal Co v Reid (1858) 3 Macq 266.............................................................................. 88,............................................................................................................................................................... 400

Beattie v Lord Napier (1831) 9 S 639......................................................................................................

Berry v Berry (No 2) 1989 SLT 292....................................................................................................... 172

Binning v Brotherstones (1676) Mor 13401.................................................................................. 185,............................................................................................................................................................... 224

Black v Incorporation of Bakers, Glasgow (1867) 6 M 136................................................................ 234

Boskabelle v Laird 2006 SLT 1079......................................................................................................... 223

Brand's Trs v Brand's Trs (1876) 3 R (HL) 16........................................................................................ 224

Brock v Hamilton (1852) 19 D 701......................................................................................................... 172

Brogan v O'Rourke Ltd 2005 SCLR 337.................................................................................................... 51

Brown v Marr (1880) 7 R 427.......................................................................................................... 337,............................................................................................................................................................... 381

B's Executor v Keeper of the Registers and Records of Scotland 1935 SC 745............................... 294

Burnett's Trustee v Grainger 2004 SC (HL) 19.............................................................................. 163,............................................................................................................................................................... 202

C v Chief Constable of the Police Service of Scotland [2019] CSOH 48, 2019 SLT 875

(Outer House); [2019] CSIH 61 (Inner House).............................................................................

Campbell v Campbell (1866) 4 M 867.................................................................................................. 141

Cantiere San Rocco, SA v Clyde Shipbuilding & Engineering Co Ltd 1923 SC (HL) 105.............. 432

Charleston v News Group Newspapers Ltd [1995] 2 AC 65................................................................ 414

Chief Constable, Strathclyde Police v Sharp 2002 SLT (Sh Ct) 95..................................................... 191

Chowan v Associated Motor Holdings (Pty) Ltd 2018 (4) SA 145..................................................... 385

Christie v Smith's Executrix 1949 SC 572.............................................................................................. 222

Clark v Lindale Homes Ltd 1994 SC 210................................................................................................ 360

Clydesdale Bank plc v Black 2002 SC 555............................................................................................... 99

Cochrane v Stevenson (1891) 18 R 1208............................................................................................... 222

Compugraphics International Ltd v Nikolic 2011 SLT 955............ 249 Costello v Chief Constable of Derbyshire Constabulary [2001] EWCA Civ 381,

[2001] WLR 1437.............................................................................................................................. 173

Cowan v Bennett 2012 GWD 37-738...................................................................................................... 412

Crown Estate Commissioners v Fairlie Yacht Slip Ltd 1979 SC 156................................................. 197

Dean v Lord Advocate [2019] HCJAC 31................................................................................................. 87

Donoghue v Stevenson 1932 SC (HL) 31........................................................... 399-400, 401, 402, 403

Dorion v Les Ecclesiastiques du Seminaire de St Sulpice de Montreal (1880) 5 App Cas 362.....

Douglas v Douglas (1876) 4 R 105.......................................................................................................... 291

Douglas v Duke of Hamilton (1769) 2 Pat 143...................................................................................... 122

Dowall v Milne (1874) 1 R 1180.............................................................................................................. 223

Drake v Dow 2006 SCLR 456................................................................................................................... 444

Duke of Hamilton vJohnston (1877) 14 SLR 298................................................................................. 224

Duke of Roxburghe v Duchess Dowager of Roxburghe 19 Jan 1816, FC.......................................... 263

Dumbreck v Robert Addie & Sons (Collieries) Ltd 1929 SC (HL) 51................................................ 401

Duncan v MFV Marigold PD145 2006 SLT 975.................................................................................... 377

Eadie v Young (1815) Hume 705............................................................................................................. 212

English v Thomas Sanderson Ltd [2008] EWCA Civ 1421, [2009] 2 CMLR 18.............................. 413

Fairchild v Glenhaven Funeral Services Ltd [2003] 1 AC 32..................................................... 397,............................................................................................................................................................... 403

Faulds v Townsend (1861) 23 D 437....................................................................................................... 183

Fernie v Robertson (1871) 9 M 437........................................................................................................ 435

Ferrier v Walker (1832) 10 S 317............................................................................................................

Fife Assessor v Hodgson 1966 SC 30...................................................................................................... 223

Franklin v Lawson 2013 SLT (Lands Tr) 81........................................................................................... 249

Gibbs v Ruxton 2000 JC 258...................................................................................................................... 29

Grant v Henry (1894) 21 R 358............................................................................................................... 196

Gray v Dunlop 1954 SLT (Sh Ct) 75........................................................................................................ 440

Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller & Partners Ltd [1964] AC 465........................................................ 328

Henderson v Chief Constable, Fife Police 1988 SLT 361.................................................................... 415

Hetherington v Galt (1905) 7 F 706......................................................................................................... 223

Hogg v Gow 27 May 1812, FC.................................................................................................................. 137

Howie's Trs v McLay (1902) 5 F 214...................................................................................................... 223

Hughes v Lord Advocate 1963 SC (HL) 31............................................................................................ 394

Innes v Magistrates of Edinburgh (1798) Mor 13189.................................................................. 195,............................................................................................................................................................... 400

International Banking Corporation v Ferguson, Shaw & Sons 1910 SC 182............................ 234,...............................................................................................................................................................

Irvine Knitters Ltd v North Ayrshire Co-operative Society Ltd 1978 SC 109.................................. 247

J L Cohen Motors SWA (Pty) Ltd v Alberts 1985 (2) SA 427............................................................. 238

Johnson, Thomas and Thomas (A Firm) v Smith 2016 GWD 25-456................................................ 250

Joint Liquidators of Scottish Coal v Scottish Environmental Protection Agency 2014 SC 372.... 221

Keith v Texaco Ltd 1977 SLT (Lands Tr) 16.......................................................................................... 254

Kerr v Brown 1939 SC 140....................................................................................................................... 248

Kerr v Martin (1840) 2 D 752.................................................................................................................. 126

Khaliq v HM Advocate 1984JC 23.......................................................................................................... 395

Khan v Minister of Law and Order 1991 (3) SA 439............................................................................ 229

Kidson v Jimspeed Enterprises CC 2009 (5) SA 246............................................................................ 267

Kinloch Damph Ltd v Nordvik Salmon Farms Ltd 30 June 1999 Outer House................................ 236

Kirkpatrick v Murray (1856) 19 D 91..................................................................................................... 256

Knight v Wedderburn (1778) Mor 14545.............................................................................................. 103

Kolbin & Sons v Kinnear & Co 1930 SC 724........................................................................................ 435

Le Roux v Dey [2011] ZACC 4, 2011 (3) SA 274................................................................................. 414

Leitch v Fairy (1711) Mor 13946............................................................................................................ 439

Lewars v Hay (1712) 4 Bro Sup 894....................................................................................................... 439

Lockhart v Cunninghame (1870) 8 SLR 151.......................................................................................... 391

Lord Advocate v Aberdeen University 1963 SC 533........................................................................... 238

McCaig v University of Glasgow 1907 SC 231..................................................................................... 294

McCaig’s Trustees v Kirk Session of United Free Church of Lismore 1915 SC 426....................... 294

Macdonald v Aberdeenshire Council [2013] CSIH 83, 2014 SC 114...................................... 195,............................................................................................................................................................... 403

McDonald v Provan (of Scotland Street) Limited 1960 SLT 231....................................................... 234

Macdonald v Watson (1830) 8 S 584...................................................................................................... 256

McDyer v The Celtic Football and Athletic Co Ltd 2000 SC 379.............................................. 440,............................................................................................................................................................... 441

Mackenzie v Mackenzie’s Trs 1916 1 SLT 349.................................................................................... 141

Mackenzie v Maclean 1981 SLT (Sh Ct) 40.................................................................................. 220,............................................................................................................................................................... 418

Mackie v Mackie 1917 SC 276............................................................................................................... 140

McLaren, Sons & Co Ltd v Mann, Byars & Co Ltd (1935) 51 Sh Ct Rep 57..................................... 234

Macleod v Kerr 1965 SC 253........................................................................................................... 207,............................................................................................................................................................... 330

McTaggart v Macdouall (1867) 5 M 534................................................................................................ 247

Maloy v McCosh (1885) 12 R 431.......................................................................................................... 140

Marjandi Ltd v Bon Accord Glass Ltd 15 October 2007, Aberdeen Sheriff Court.......................... 366

Martin v McGuinness 2003 SLT 1424.................................................................................................... 415

Matheson v Stewart (1872) 10 M 704.................................................................................................... 181

May v Wingate (1694) Mor 9236............................................................................................................ 443

Miller v HM Advocate [2019] HCJAC 7................................................................................................ 103

Milligan v Ross 1994 SCLR 430.............................................................................................................. 214

Moncrieff v Jamieson 2008 SC (HL) 1.................................................................................. 248,.... 250, 252

More v Boyle 1967 SLT (Sh Ct) 38......................................................................................................... 167

Morgan Guaranty Trust Co of New York v Lothian Regional Council 1995 SC 151................. 432-3

Morrisson v Robertson 1908 SC 332..................................................................................... 205,.... 207, 330

Muirhead & Turnbull v Dickson (1905) 7 F 686................................................................................... 331

Mullen v Barr & Co; McGowan v Barr & Co 1929 SC 461................................................................. 401

Mustard v Paterson 1923 SC 142............................................................................................................. 443

Nacap Ltd v Moffat Plant Ltd 1987 SLT 221........................................................................................ 398

Nisbet’s Creditors v Robertson (1791) Mor 9554................................................................................. 270

O’Keeffe v Argus Printing and Publishing Co Ltd 1954 (3) SA 244.................................................. 413

Oliver & Boyd v The Marr Typefounding Co Ltd (1901) 9 SLT 170........................................ 232,............................................................................................................................................................... 235

Ord v Mashford 2006 SLT (Lands Tr) 15............................................................................................... 249

Orr’s Trustee v Tullis (1870) 8 M 936.................................................................................................... 214

Pert v McCaffrey [2020] CSIH 5, 2020 SLT 225................................................................................... 434

Petrie v Petrie 1911 SC 360...................................................................................................................... 140

PMP Plus Ltd v Keeper of the Registers of Scotland 2009 SLT (Lands Tr) 2................................... 207

R v Mafohla 1958 (2) SA 373................................................................................................................... 221

Raffles v Wichelhaus (1864) 159 ER 375.............................................................................................. 328

Reid v Scott of Harden (1687) Mor 9505..................................................................................... 103,............................................................................................................................................................... 105

Roscorla v Thomas (1842) 3 QB 234...................................................................................................... 327

Royal Bank of Scotland plc v Etridge (No 2) [2002] 2 AC 773............................................................. 99

S v Mnomiya 1970 (1) SA 66.................................................................................................................... 228

S v S 2006 SLT 471.................................................................................................................................... 141

Safeway Stores plc v Tesco Stores Ltd 2004 SC 29.............................................................................. 174

Satchwell v McIntosh 2006 SLT (Sh Ct) 117......................................................................................... 434

Scammell v Scottish Sports Council 1983 SLT 462.............................................................................. 196

Scot v Forbes (1755) Mor 8278....................................................................................................... 264,............................................................................................................................................................... 267

Scott v Everitt (1853) 15 D 288................................................................................................................ 221

Scott v Yates (1800) Hume 207................................................................................................................ 443

Scottish Transit Trust Ltd v Scottish Land Cultivators Ltd 1955 SC 254.......................................... 214

Scrimgeour v Scrimgeour 1988 SLT 590................................................................................................ 172

Shields v Donnelly 2000 JC 46................................................................................................................... 29

Shilliday v Smith 1998 SC 725................................................................................................................. 433

Simmons v British Steel plc 2004 SC (HL) 94....................................................................................... 394

Simpson v Duncanson’s Creditors (1786) Mor 14204......................................................................... 228

Sloans Dairies Ltd v Glasgow Corporation 1977 SC 223..................................................................... 357

Smith v Bank of Scotland 1997 SC (HL) 111........................................................................................... 99

Sneddon v Durant 1982 SLT (Sh Ct) 39.................................................................................................. 355

Stevens v Yorkhill NHS Trust [2006] CSOH 143, 2006 SLT 889....................................................... 415

Stewart v Kennedy (1890) 17 R (HL) 25................................................................................................ 331

Stewart v Sinclair (1694) 4 Bro Sup 195................................................................................................ 439

Stichting Crediteurenbelangen Hollander’s v Coöperatieve Raiffeissenbank ‘Domburg’

24 March 1995, Hoge Raad (Netherlands).................................................................................... 236

Stilk v Meyrick (1809) 170 ER 851......................................................................................................... 327

Stirling v Bartlett 1993 SLT 763............................................................................................................... 226

Stove v Colvin (1831) 9 S 633.................................................................................................................. 221

Stronach’s Executors v Robertson 2002 SC 540................................................................................... 265

Sutter v Aberdeen Arctic Co (1861) 23 D 465 (Court of Session), (1862) 4 Macq 355

(House of Lords)................................................................................................................................ 221

Thomson v Clarkson’s Trustees (1892) 20 R 59................................................................................... 298

Tolley vJ S Fry & Sons Ltd [1931] AC 333............................................................................................ 413

Trotter v Trotter 2001 SLT (Sh Ct) 42.................................................................................................... 270

Valentine v Kennedy 1985 SCCR 89....................................................................................................... 221

Vincent v Lake Erie Transportation Company (1910) 109 Minn. 456, 124 N.W. 221.................... 392

W S Karoulias SA v Drambuie Liqueur Co Ltd (No 2) 2005 SLT 813........................................... 332-3

Walker v Milne (1823) 2 S 379................................................................................................................ 332

Wardlaw v Wardlaw’s Trs (1875) 2 R 368............................................................................................. 263

Watling v McDowall (1825) 4 S 83......................................................................................................... 443

Watt v Jamieson 1954 SC 56.................................................................................................................... 167

Welsh v Russell (1894) 21 R 769............................................................................................................. 359

Williamson v White 21June 1810, FC..................................................................................................... 443

Williamson v Williamson 1997 SC 94.................................................................................................... 295

Wills’ Trustees v Cairngorm Canoeing and Sailing School Ltd 1976 SC (HL) 30........................... 196

Wilson v Dykes (1872) 10 M 444............................................................................................................ 221

Wilson & McLellan v Sinclair (1830) 4 W & S 398............................................................................. 433

Wylie & Lochhead v Mitchell (1870) 8 M 552............................................................................. 231,............................................................................................................................................................... 236

X v Y 1921 1 SLT 79.................................................................................................................................. 140

Zahnrad Fabrik Passau GmbH v Terex 1985 SC 364............................................................................ 231