On 14 November 1976 a young woman named Kim Ham-Bin was arrested and detained at a secretive prison designated ‘S-21'.
Located in Phnom Penh, the security-centre was established as one of approximately 200 detainment sites located throughout Democratic Kampuchea - as Cambodia was renamed. During its brief existence, roughly between October 1975 and January 1979, upwards of 12,000 men, women and children were warehoused under inhumane conditions.
Many were tortured and forced to confess to various crimes; all but a handful were eventually executed, either within the broader S-21 compound or at the nearby ‘killing fields' known as Cheoung Ek.Little is known of Kim Ham-Bin. Archives from S-21 indicate that she was 25 years old. Her ‘position' is recorded simply as ‘wife of Chhim Sak'. No documents have survived that might indicate why she was arrested - other than the fact that she was the wife of Chhim Sak. As to Chhim Sak, he was arrested on 16 January 1976 and executed on 22 July 1976 - three months prior to his wife's arrest.
On the day of Kim Ham-Ban's detainment, forty-five other people were arrested. Of these, at least forty were women, all of whom were classified as ‘wife', ‘mother' or ‘sister' of other detainees. And with few exceptions, all of these women, including Kim Ham-Bin, were executed within twenty-four hours.
Since the collapse of Democratic Kampuchea, the security-centre known as S-21 has assumed a prominent role in the ongoing historiography of the Cambodian genocide. As an institution, S-21 calls attention to the administered violence that was manifest in Cambodia. Undue focus on S-21, however, deflects attention from other, more systemic forms of violence that enabled the security-centre to function.
From its inception as a disorganised socio-political movement, the Communist Party of Kampuchea (CPK; aka the ‘Khmer Rouge') emerged as one of the most violent and brutal apparatus of state terror and murder since the Nazi party held power in Germany.
Between April 1975 and January 1979 approximately 2 million people died from starvation, disease, exposure, torture, murder and execution. Historians and other scholars have attempted to understand how this mass violence could have taken place, with particular emphasis focused on the allegedly ‘extreme' or ‘radical' variant of Marxist-Leninist doctrine forwarded by the Khmer Rouge. Indeed, something of a caricature of the Khmer Rouge has emerged, as the CPK has variously been compared to Peru's ‘Shining Path' and, most recently, to al- Qaeda and ISIS - the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria.The dominant interpretation of Cambodian history during this period, described by Michael Vickery as the ‘Standard Total View' (STV), presents the CPK as a totalitarian, communist and autarkic regime seeking to reorganise Cambodian society around a primitive, agrarian political economy.1 Under the STV, the victims of the regime perished as a consequence of the structural violence of misguided and irrational economic policies, a draconian security apparatus implemented to instil terror, and the central leadership's fanatical belief in the creation of a utopian communist society. Notable here is the blame laid upon Pol Pot, the highly secretive and paranoid leader of the CPK. Under the Khmer Rouge, following the STV, cities were emptied; hospitals and schools destroyed; and religion, currency and private property were abolished. To this end, Stewart Clegg and coauthors write, ‘the Khmer Rouge embarked on creating an agrarian, egalitarian, anti-professional, anti-technology and self-sufficient society - a primate communist utopia'.[875] [876]
For Vickery, the STV limits our understanding of CPK ideology, policies and practice to such an extent that its presumptions of CPK autarky and despotism have become conventional wisdom. These latter presumptions have permeated not only scholarly accounts, but also popular understandings and journalistic commentaries.
Consequently, the STV has become the interpretative framework for understanding the Cambodian genocide: a taken-for-granted historiography into which new evidence is either accommodated or ignored. Thus, Greg Procknow is able to write that CPK policies ‘converted the bourgeoning capitalist economy into a communistic, ruralcentric, independent, self-sustainable nation, with an emphasis on selfmastery. Money was abolished, foreign trade collapsed.'[877]
It is not so much that the STV is inaccurate as that it is incomplete and theoretically vapid. In fact, documentary evidence indicates that the CPK sold rice surpluses on the global market to satisfy the state's need for fertiliser, tractors, industrial inputs and provisions.[878] Ben Kiernan finds also that agricultural exports were traded for artillery, coastal patrol boats and other weaponry.[879] Rhetoric aside, the regime's consolidation of control was not based on an irrational foundation of self-reliance and self-mastery. Instead, as I document in this chapter, CPK policy was predicated upon surplus agricultural production and a selective engagement with the global economy as informed by its allegiance to the Non-Aligned Movement. Accordingly, I challenge standard historiography of the Cambodian genocide by providing an analytical overview of the structures of violence set in place by the Khmer Rouge. First, however, it is necessary to provide a broader geopolitical framework from which to understand the emergence of the CPK as a political organisation that would come to orchestrate genocidal violence upon its own people.
More on the topic On 14 November 1976 a young woman named Kim Ham-Bin was arrested and detained at a secretive prison designated ‘S-21'.:
- The right of the young woman to choose her life partner
- Being a woman in Aceh at this time is not easy. Everywhere you go people’s eyes are on your dress and your head. They look at how you dress and how you cover your hair and from there they judge whether you are a good or a bad woman. (Interview, Banda Aceh, 20 December 2007)
- What,s Wrong with the Prison Industrial Complex?
- Designated Hospitals
- Designated Hospitals
- Kim A. Wagner
- Marco A. Janssen and Kim Hill
- Nitin K. Saksena[*], Jing Qin Wu, Katherine Lau, Li Zhou, Maly Soedjono and Bin Wang
- About 14 years ago, Kim and Factor reported the first case of HIV-associated pulmonary hypertension[1].
- B. Early Christian Interpretations of the Woman Clothed with the Sun
- 8.01 The Agriculture (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1976 radically extended the security of tenure for farm tenants by introducing a statutory succession scheme enabling a close relative of a deceased tenant to succeed to the tenancy.
- Instruments for Use With Young Children
- OUTPATIENT MANAGEMENT OF CHILDREN BELOW 2 MONTHS (SICK YOUNG INFANTS)
- Bin Q. Yang, Justin C. Hartupee, Justin M. Vader
- An Unnamed Woman Anoints Jesus for Burial (14:3-9)
- Michel Foucault's provocative critique of the modern prison system, first published in 1975, raises important questions about the evolution of justice in the West.