<<
>>

Conclusion

This chapter examined the lived realities of marriage and divorce among British Muslims and highlighted the importance of nikah in establishing the marriage and Islamic divorce to end a marriage.

The insights gained from the professionals and the observation of the Sha­riah Council show they have an awareness of the civil law and provide services accordingly. Civil marriage was recommended to provide Muslim women protection and rights, and access to civil courts in the event of a marital breakdown. Also, a civil divorce could be relevant where a Shariah Council accepts it as evidencing a religious divorce. However, for many women and religious establishments, the Islamic divorce supersedes any civil divorce, and therefore the reforms and regulations proposed in this chapter seek to improve standards among Shariah Councils and other forums that provide services to Muslim women seeking an Islamic divorce.

Notes

1 Samfa Bano, Muslim Women and Sharfah Councils; Transcending the Boundaries of Community and Law (Palgrave Macmillan 2012) 84.

2 Pragna Patel, ‘Sharia Courts Have No Place in UK Family Law. Listen to Women Who Know’ The Guardian (London, 14 December 2016); Elham Manea, Womewawd Slalia Law; Tie Impact of τ^e^j^c^l PlwTalismiw tie UK (I.B. Tauris 2016).

Gillian Douglas, Norman Doe, Sophie Gilliat-Ray, Russell Sandberg, a AAsma Khan., SocialclesiowawdReligiousLaMwMaTTiaDivoTCe awd Religious Courts (Cardiff Law School 2011).

Sara Khan, ‘Muslim Marriages Like George Galloway’s Should Be Registered’ The Guardiaw (London, 4 May 2012).

Home Office, ‘The Independent Review into the Application of Sharia Law in England and Wales’ (2018) accessed 2 September 2020.

Farrah Ahmed and Jane Calderwood Norton, ‘Religious Tribunals, Religious Freedom, and Concern for Vulnerable Women’ 24 child awd Family LawQartela! 363, 2012.,

Patel; Manea Maryam Namazie, Yassi Atasheen, Anna Waters, and MureLSeLtman, Sharia Law iw Lritaiw-.

A Threat to Owe Law for All ⅛ Equal Rights (One Law for All 2010).

MaLehaMaLL,, Mliworita Legal Orders iw the UK: Miworities, Pluralism awd the Law (The British Academy 2012).

Home Office, ‘Independent Review into Sharia Law Launched’ (2016) accessed 2 September 2020.

Home Office, ‘The Independent Review into the Application of Sharia Law in England and Wales’.

Home Office, ‘Faith Practices: Written statement - HCWS442’ (2018) accessed 2 September 2020.

ONS, 2011 Cewsus (Office for National Statistics 2011).

Sophie Gilliat-Ray, Muslims iw Britaiw (Cambridge University Press 2010).

Edward E Curtis, IV (ed) Ewcyclopedia of Muslim-Americaw History (Infobase Publishing 2010) 154.

Tariq Ramadan, Westerw Muslims awd the Future of Islam (Oxford Uni­versity Press 2004) 139.

Rebecca Probert, ‘The Evolving Concept of Non-Marriage' 25 child awd Family Law Quarterly 314, 2013.

Ramadan 139-140; Habiba Jaan, Equal awd Free? 50 Muslim Womew’s ExperiewcesofMarriageiwBritaiw Today LAurat 201

Ahmed and Norton.

Arbitration and Mediation Services (Equality) Bill (2016-17) Marriage Act 1949 (Amendment) Bill (2017-19).

Home Office, ‘The Independent Review into the Application of Sharia Law in England and Wales’.

Rakesh Kumar Singh, Textbook ow Muslim Law (Universal Law Publishing 2011).

Judith E Tucker, Womew, Family, awd Gewder iw Islamic Law (Cam­bridge University Press 2008).

Ann Laquer Estin, ‘Unofficial Family Law’ 94 Iowa Law Review 449, 2008; Anika Liversage, ‘Secrets and Lies: When Ethnic Minority Have Nikah' in Prakash Shah, Marie-Claire Foblets and Mathias Rohe (eds), FamilyiReIigionandLaw--CuIturaIEncountersinEurope (,Ashgate Pub­lishing Ltd 2014).

Ann Black, ‘In the Shadow of Our Legal System: Shari'a in Australia' in Rex J Ahdar and Nicholas Aroney (eds), Shari’a in the West (Oxford Uni­versity Press 2010); Julie Macfarlane, Islamic Divorce in North America: A Shari’a Path in a Secular Society (Oxford University Press 2012).

Rajnaara C Akhtar, ‘Unregistered Muslim Marriages: An Emerging Cul­ture of Celebrating Rites and Compromising Rights' in JK Miles, P Mody and R Probert (eds), Marriage Rites and Rights (Bloomsbury Publishing 2015).

John L Esposito and Natana J DeLong-Bas, Women in Muslim Family Law (2nd edn, Syracuse University Press 2001); Raffia Arshad, Islamic Family Law (Sweet & Maxwell/Thomson Reuters 2010).

Abdullahi Ahmed An-Naim (ed), Islamic Family Law in a Changing WorId--AGIobaIResourceBook Zed Books 2002).

Elizabeth Butler-Sloss and Mark Hill, ‘Family Law: Current Conflicts and Their Resolution' in Robin Griffith-Jones (ed), Islam and English Law: Rights, Responsibilities, ^^d the PIaee of Shari’a (,Cambridge University Press 2013).

Crown, DO SupportingNotesfor Guidanee on CompIetinga Divoreel DissoIutionlffudieiaI) Separation Petition (,HM Courts & Tribunals Service 2014).

Curtis Macfarlane.

Ihsan Yilmaz, ‘The Challenge of Post-Modern Legality and Muslim Le­gal Pluralism in England' 28 Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 343, 2002; Jemma Wilson, ‘Sharia Debate in Britain: Sharia Councils and the Oppression of Muslim Women' 1 The Aberdeen Student Law Review 46, 2010.

Nigel V Lowe and Gillian Douglas, Bromley’s Family Law (Oxford Uni­versity Press 2015); David Pearl and Werner Menski, Muslim Family Law (3rd edn, Sweet & Maxwell 1998).

Charlotte Proudman, ‘Religious Marriages: Staying a Decree Absolute in Order to Increase the Chances of Obtaining a Religious Divorce' (Family Law Week, 2013) accessed 2 September 2020; Ahmed and Norton Shaista Gohir, ‘Listening to Muslim Women on Sharia Divorce Could Change It for the Better' The Guardian (London, 1 November 2016).

Federica Sona, ‘Defending the Family Treasure Chest: Navigating Mus­lim Families and Secured Positivistic Islands of European Legal Systems' in Prakash Shah, Marie-Claire Foblets and Mathias Rohe (eds), Family, Religion and Law: Cultural Encounters in Europe (Ashgate Publishing Ltd 2014).

Bano 92.

SN Shah-Kazemi, Untying the Knot: Muslim Women, Divorce ^^d the Shariah (The Nuffield Foundation 2001) 56.

Haitham Al-Haddad, ‘Fatwa: A Civil Divorce Is Not a Valid Islamic Divorce' (2010) accessed 2 September 2020; Muhammad Saalih Al-Munajjid, ‘Documenting Divorce in a Civil, Non-Islamic Court' (Islam QA, 2010) accessed 2 September 2020.

38 Bano 84.

39 Macfarlane Ghena Krayem, Islamic Family Law in Australia ISS 16: To Recognise or Not to Recognise (Melbourne University Publishing 2014).

40 John RBowetr, OnBiitisl Islam:-. Religion,Law, and Everyday Practice in Shari'a Councils (Princeton University Press 2016) 47.

41 Denis MacEoin, Sharia Law Or ‘One Law for All?’ (Civitas 2009) 69.

42 SBano, AnExploratory Study of Shariah CouncilsinEnglandwith Re­spect to Family Law (Ministry of Justice and the University of Reading 2012) 15.

43 CarohneCox, AParalelWordConfrontingtheAbuseofMany Muslim Women in Britain Today (The Bow Group 2015).

44 Manea.

45 JCNorton,The Freedom of Religious Organizations (,Oxford Un ver ty Press 2016) 43.

46 K Qureshr, Marital Breakdown among British Asians-. Conjugality, Legal Pluralism and New Kinship (Palgrave Macmillan 2016) 172.

Bibliography

Arbitration ^^d Mediation Services Equality) Bill (,2016-17).

Ahmed F and Norton JC, ‘Religious Tribunals, Religious Freedom, and Con­cern for Vulnerable Women’ 24 Child and Family Law Quarterly 363, 2012.

Akhtar RC, ‘Unregistered Muslim Marriages: An Emerging Culture of Cele­brating Rites and Compromising Rights’ in Miles JK, Mody P and Probert R (eds), Marriage Rites and Rights (Bloomsbury Publishing 2015).

Al-Haddad H, ‘Fatwa: A Civil Divorce Is Not a Valid Islamic Divorce’ (2010) accessed 2 September 2020.

Al-Munajjid MS, ‘Documenting Divorce in a Civil, Non-Islamic Court’ (Islam QA, 2010) accessed 2 September 2020.

An-Nafmr AA (ed) Islamic Family Law InaChanging World-. Adc^l^c^l Re­source Book (Zed Books 2002).

Arshad R, Islamic Family Law (Sweet & Maxwell/Thomson Reuters 2010).

Bano B, AnExploratory Study of Shariah CounclsinEnglandwith Respect to Family Law (Ministry of Justice and the University of Reading 2012).

—, Muslim Womenand Shariah Councils-. Transcending the Bounda­ries of Community and Law (Palgrave Macmillan 2012).

Black A, ‘In the Shadow of Our Legal System: Shari’a in Australia’ in Ahdar RJ and Aroney N (eds), Shari’a in the West (Oxford University Press 2010).

Bowen JW, On British Islam-. Religion, Law, and Everyday Practice in Shari'a Councils (Princeton University Press 2016).

Butler-Sloss E and Hill M, ‘Family Law: Current Conflicts and Their Resolu- ton’ InGrffhft-Jones Red),IslamandEnglish Law-. Rights, Resjionsibil- ities, and the Place of Shari’a (Cambridge University Press 2013).

CoxC, A-ParaIIeI WorId--CoMfronting IeAbrtseof Many MIin Won en in Britain Today (The Bow Group 2015).

CCrown-, D008 Supporting ‰tes for Guidance on Completing a Divorce, DissoIutionJffudiciaI) Separation Petition HM Courts & Tribunals Service 2014).

Curtis EE, IV (ed) EncycIopedia of MusIim-American History (Infobase Publishing 2010).

Divorce (Religious Marriages) Act.

Domicile and Matrimonial Proceedings Act.

Douglas G Doe, N, Gilliat-Ray, S, Sandberg, R, Khan, A, SociaI Cohesion UdReIigiousLaMarriageDivorceandReIigiousCouts CardiffLaw School 2011).

Equality Act.

Esposito JL and DeLong-Bas NJ, Women in MusIim FamiIy Law (2nd edn, Syracuse University Press 2001).

Estin AL, ‘Unofficial Family Law’ 94 Iowa Law Review 449, 2008.

Gilliat-Ray S, MusIims in Britain (Cambridge University Press 2010).

Gohir S, ‘Listening to Muslim Women on Sharia Divorce Could Change It for the Better’ The Guardian (London, 1 November 2016).

Home Office, ‘Independent Review into Sharia Law Launched’ (2016) accessed 2 September 2020.

———, ‘Faith Practices: Written statement - HCWS442’ (2018) accessed 2 September 2020.

———, ‘The Independent Review into the Application of Sharia Law in Eng­land and Wales’ (2018) accessed 2 September 2020.

Jaan H-, EquI and Free? 50 Muslim Women’s Experiences of Marriage in Britain Today (Aurat 2014).

Khan S, ‘Muslim Marriages Like George Galloway’s Should Be Registered’ The Guardian (London, 4 May 2012).

KrayemG, IsIamicFamiIy LawinAustraIiaISSLb-. To KecogniseOr ‰tto Recognise (Melbourne University Publishing 2014).

Liversage A, ‘Secrets and Lies: When Ethnic Minority Have Nikah’ in Shah P, Foblets M-C and Rohe M (eds), FamiIy, ReIigion and Law: CuIturaI Encounters in Europe (Ashgate Publishing Ltd 2014).

Lowe NV and Douglas G, BromIey’s FamiIy Law (Oxford University Press 2015).

MacEoin D, Sharia Law Or ‘One Law for AII?’ (Civitas 2009).

MacfarIaneJ, IsIamicDivorceinblorth AmericaASharPaPath InaSecuIar Society (Oxford University Press 2012).

Malik ì, MiwoTity OtcCts ³„ tie IlM MiwoTities, PlMTalisrnawd tie

Law (The British Academy 2012).

Manea E, WomewawdSlaTiaLaw-. TlelmpactofLegalPlMTalismiwtleLL- (I.B. Tauris 2016).

Marriage Act.

Marriage Act 1949 (Amewdmewt) Bill (2017-19).

Matrimonial Causes Act.

Namazie M, Atasheen, Y, Waters, A, and Seltman, M, ShaTia Law iw BTit- aiw-.ATleattoOweLawfoTAll⅛ LqtalRightS One Law forALL20101.

Norton JC, The pTeedom of ReligioMS OTgawiatiows !Oxford UniverAty Press 2016).

ONS, 2011 CewSMS (Office for National Statistics 2011).

Patel P, ‘Sharia Courts Have No Place in UK Family Law. Listen to Women Who Know’ The GtaTdiaw (London, 14 December 2016).

Pearl D and Menski W, Mtslim Family Law (3rd edn, Sweet & Maxwell 1998).

Probert R, ‘The Evolving Concept of Non-Marriage’ 25 Child awd Family Law QtaTteTly 314, 2013.

Proudman C, ‘Religious Marriages: Staying a Decree Absolute in Order to Increase the Chances of Obtaining a Religious Divorce’ (Family Law Weeh, 2013) accessed 2 September 2020.

Qureslri K-, MaTital BTeakdoww amowg BTitish Asiaws-. CoWfMgality, Legal PltTalism awd New Kiwship (Palgrave Macmillan 2016).

Ramadan T, WesteTw Mtslims awd the FttMTe of lslam !Oxford UniverAty Press 2004).

Shalr-KazenASN, UwtyiwgtheKwotMtslim Womew,DivoTceawd the Sha- Tiah (The Nuffield Foundation 2001).

Singh RK, Textbook ow Mtslim Law (Universal Law Publishing 2011).

Sona F, ‘Defending the Family Treasure Chest: Navigating Muslim Fami­lies and Secured Positivistic Islands of European Legal Systems’ in Shah P, Foblets M-C and Rohe M (eds), Family, Religiow awd Law: CtlttTal EwcotwteTs iw EtTope (Ashgate Publishing Ltd 2014).

Tucker JE, WomewFamilyawdGewdeTiwlslamicLaw !Cambridge Univer­sity Press 2008).

Wilson J, ‘Sharia Debate in Britain: Sharia Councils and the Oppression of Muslim Women’ 1 The AbeTdeew Sttdewt Law Review 46, 2010.

Yilmaz I, ‘The Challenge of Post-Modern Legality and Muslim Legal Plural­ism in England’ 28 JotTwal of Ethwic awd MigTatiow Sttdies 343, 2002.

4

<< | >>
Source: Bano Samia (ed.). The Sharia Inquiry, Religious Practice and Muslim Family Law in Britain. Routledge,2023. — 143 p.. 2023
More legal literature on Laws.Studio

More on the topic Conclusion:

  1. Conclusion
  2. Conclusion
  3. Conclusion
  4. CONCLUSION
  5. Conclusion
  6. Conclusion
  7. Conclusion
  8. Conclusion
  9. Conclusion: where to next?
  10. Conclusion
  11. 5.5 CONCLUSION
  12. CONCLUSION
  13. Conclusion