Conclusion
In sum, medieval literature is filled with cases of violent behaviour, not only within a military setting, but also often in domestic and private contexts. Poets regularly engaged with this topic and treated it from different perspectives.
The reason for this great interest is not hard to understand because violence always tends to disrupt all social conditions and undermines ethical, moral, religious and philosophical norms and ideals. Marie de France deeply problematised personal violence and viewed it critically, though even she projected cases where the evaluation of personal violence proves to be not straightforward, as in ‘Bisclavret'. In the Nibelungenlied we seem to be asked to condemn Hagen as a brutal murderer, but there are many alternative perspectives that could cast his action in a different light. He kills Siegfried both out of personal concerns and for political reasons and thus operates both beyond the law and outside of all ethical standards. In Mai und Beaflor, Eliacha's strategies could have led to horrible murder, but Beaflor and her son survive because they enjoy so much emotional support and can escape in time. While the narrator strictly condemns this mother-in-law for her vicious character, Mai's matricide is viewed almost positively because he kills a truly evil person. Boccaccio, on the other hand, almost like a psychologist, presents many cases of violent behaviour resulting in the victims' death, condemning the motivations and suggesting in strong terms that excessive passion such as lust is to be blamed for these murders. Finally, Kaufringer treats a case of triple murder, but here we are asked to evaluate it very differently and to condone the woman's actions because she committed those murders virtually in self-defence.Just as the topic of love and death emerged in medieval literature, so too does the theme of violence appear. As the examples reveal, medieval poets and their audiences were obviously deeply concerned with this issue and debated its causes, consequences and etiology in a highly complex manner. Violence was ubiquitous, and yet the many different literary voices undoubtedly signalled how perpetrations and transgressions were viewed highly critically. Violence is not simply violence; much depends on the circumstances, the motivations, the intention, and the general framework within which it is committed. In other words, just as today, medieval poets reflected the great need to think about violence, to evaluate its etiology, and contain or remove it by legal means, by better communication, and by laws, of course. Nevertheless, personal violence is often actually described as necessary, logical and unavoidable in order to protect one’s honour or the well-being of a kingdom, or to punish evil-doers. But in every case discussed here we notice how much violence is described as caused by emotions, passion and lack of self-control.
More on the topic Conclusion:
- Conclusion
- Conclusion
- Conclusion
- CONCLUSION
- Conclusion
- Conclusion
- Conclusion
- Conclusion
- Conclusion: where to next?
- Conclusion
- 5.5 CONCLUSION
- CONCLUSION
- Conclusion
- CONCLUSION AND REFLECTIONS
- Conclusion The Pyramid of Peace: Past, Present and Future
- Conclusion